Impact of Financial Exclusion and its impact on rural society

This blog provides an overview of the issue of financial exclusion, which impedes rural areas' ability to expand and develop on par with urban areas. Additionally, this blog aims to provide data regarding the effects of financial inclusion in India, numerous problems associated with financial exclusion, and the current state of financial services in India.

Content

  1. Introduction
  2. Concept of Financial Inclusion
  3. Government Initiatives
  4. Financial Inclusion and Rural Livelihood Generation
  5. Financial Inclusion and Financial Literacy
  6. Reasons of Uneven Financial Inclusion in India:
  7. Uneven Growth of India
  8. Concluding Remarks

Introduction

Farmers in particular and rural residents in general seek prompt financial assistance to make the best use of available resources for securing a sustainable way of life. When there is no rural financial inclusion culture, or when there is no financial help, rural people often choose to migrate to urban regions, which deepens the cycle of vulnerability and poverty. The development of an effective and efficient delivery system, together with raising awareness among rural populations in general and marginalized groups in particular, are key components to the success of financial inclusion. It is necessary to address the structures that encourage the exploitation and vulnerability of the weaker groups. Money lenders that advertise loans through dishonest tactics ought to be adequately controlled. The participation of non-government organizations working closely with rural residents would be crucial in bridging the institutional and individual gaps. The rules and regulations governing access to financial support services must be made practical and agreeable for individuals in order to advance local concepts of social entrepreneurship. A more straightforward financial aid program will make it easier for women and other clientele groups to connect with financial institutions.


Concept of Financial Inclusion

In India, the phrase "financial inclusion" has gained popularity during the past five years. The provision of banking services at an affordable price to the great majority of the underprivileged and low-income groups is known as financial inclusion (Leeladhar 2006: 73). The Committee on Financial Inclusion, led by C. Rangarajan, provides an even broader definition, defining financial inclusion as the process of providing vulnerable groups, such as weaker parts and low-income groups, with timely and appropriate credit they need at a reasonable price (Rangarajan 2008: 26). The goal of financial inclusion, a relatively recent socioeconomic idea in India, is to make financial services accessible to the poor who might not otherwise know about or be able to afford them. Despite recent economic development rates in India that have outpaced those of the majority of developed nations, the majority of the population is still unbanked. Financial capital facilitates access to banking institutions, which fosters the saving habit and boosts the nation's economy by promoting capital formation. Rural populations can advance other capitals for livelihood by saving. Additionally, they have access to additional sufficient and transparent credit through authorized financial channels. In order to boost productivity and prosperity in rural India, this will encourage the populace's entrepreneurial spirit.

The achievement of inclusive growth will be facilitated by rural financial inclusion. A timely financial aid will help people develop their business skills and solve the credit crunch issue that affects the less fortunate groups of society. Through either a supply-leading (financial development drives growth) or a demand-following (growth drives demand for financial products) pathway, financial development fosters growth.

Government Initiatives  

The government of India has taken several initiatives in this direction.
  1. The first step taken was in the year 1969 with nationalisation of the then existing banks to make the services of the bank to the common man. 
  2. In the year 1981, The National Bank for Agriculture and Rural Development (NABARD) was established to promote sustainable and equitable agriculture and rural prosperity through effective credit support, related services, institution development and other innovative initiatives. NABARD provided credit services to farmers and various subsidy schemes for handloom sector, benefitting weavers in India. 
  3. Swarnjayanti Gram Swarozgar Yojana (SGSY) initiated in the year 1999 to create avenues of self employment available to the poor, specifically Below Poverty Line (BPL) families residing in rural areas. The Self Help Groups (SHGs) were formed and linked to bank to promote activities for their livelihood by providing income generating assets. 
  4. The National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme (NREGS) was launched after the enactment of the National Rural Employment Guarantee Act in the year 2005 to provide employment for at least 100 days in a financial year. The scheme was  specifically targeted for the rural poor, willing to do unskilled manual labour. The scheme in addition to wage employment also ensures gender and social empowerment, by increased women participation and wage parity. 
  5. National Rural Livelihood Mission (NRLM) was introduced to overcome the shortcoming of SGSY in the year 2010. The motto was poverty through access to gainful self employment and improve the standards of living of the poor by building strong and sustainable grassroots institutions of the poor. The concept of ‘Bank Mitras’ was introduced to facilitate greater accessibility to bank services. 
  6. The concept of Regional Rural Banks (RRBs) was introduced in the year 1976 to cater to the special needs of the rural and semi- urban areas specifically focussing on efficient credit availability for agriculture sector.
  7. Kisan Credit Card Scheme designed to cater farmers’ credit requirements, the scheme facilitates a single window system for providing credit in activities like cultivation of crops, post harvesting expenditure, maintenance cost for assets used in agriculture, and investment requirements in agriculture and allied activities. 
SHGs are one of the most effective vehicles for promoting financial inclusion among government programs, and they have been particularly successful in the southern states like Kerala and Karnataka. However, it hasn't really increased the number of beneficiaries who have access to all of the government's programs. The degree of public involvement and ownership is a key factor in determining whether the projects succeed or fail. Because of this, initiatives to increase financial inclusion will significantly help combat the social exclusion that is still a problem in rural regions.

Financial Inclusion and Rural Livelihood Generation

Credit is crucial for amassing the other capital necessary for generating income. For instance, it is necessary to have financial capital to satisfy the purposes in order for any physical capital, such as tools and machinery, or human capital, such as health and education, to develop. On the other hand, natural, physical, social, and human capital are crucial for the development of any form of financial capital. Both these contribute to the expansion of financial capital. Therefore, it is reasonable to suppose that all means of subsistence (capitals or assets) are interconnected and strive to advance the welfare of all. Therefore, creating secure livelihoods should be a major priority. People must take on various tasks in order to support their way of life. However, the choice of livelihood depends on the options available. As a result, assets are the initial component of every life. It may also be referred to as capital or stock. It aids in maintaining the material well-being of the home. Here, "stocks of capital" refer to any stocks that produce resources or stocks that can be used now or in the future by saving during a period of excess availability. It is important to establish if the household owns, controls, claims, or accesses the assets. The majority of the poor share some fundamental traits. The most significant of these is their lack of assets, which includes their inability to own or access property as well as other types of productive assets such as skills, education, and health.

Rural India will benefit from financial inclusion by having easier access to credit and savings. As was already mentioned, credit markets make it easier to accumulate both human and material capital. These also make it possible for people to buy insurance against unfavorable health outcomes and other surprises. People's quality of life is impacted by financial exclusion either directly or indirectly because financial inclusion increases financial capital across all livelihoods. Livelihood is made up of natural, physical, social, financial, and human capital. Therefore, it is impossible to maintain a livelihood without owning the aforementioned goods. By enhancing other assets, financial capital contributes to the creation of a life and vice versa. As a result, it enhances people's general welfare. Therefore, including the rural population in the formal financial support system is vital for any rural economy.

Financial Inclusion and Financial Literacy

Inclusion in the financial system has a long history in India. It is commonly believed to refer to opening new bank locations in unbanked and rural areas. However, today's definition of financial inclusion goes beyond simply establishing bank branches in unbanked communities to extend formal financial services across the entire nation. Direct transfers utilizing technology have been considered in the context of the different limitations in the delivery of subsidies. The beneficiary must maintain a minimum of one bank account. Since constructing that many brick and mortar physical branches is logistically impractical, the focus will be on creating electronic accounts instead. Technology adaptation would be a crucial component of this financial inclusion plan. The basic goal of rural financial inclusion is to connect individuals who are still outside the scope of formal banking with banking services by reaching out to the rural masses. This necessitates teaching the formerly uninvolved rural population about the many routes available for connecting to the services, which necessitates opening bank accounts with the bank.

SHGs affiliated with banks are emerging as a low-cost alternative to traditional methods of providing financial services to the underprivileged. Therefore, improved SHG empowerment would mark an important turning point in the financial inclusion effort. Although SHGs are becoming more significant as a source of credit for the poor and marginalized, there is no evidence of their efficient internal operation. More than a billion people worldwide have access to mobile phones, but more than 2.6 billion do not have access to financial services, according to an estimate (Dermish et al. 2011).

Banks have been permitted to use the services of NGOs, self-help groups, MFIs, and other civil society organizations as intermediaries in providing financial and banking services through the use of business facilitator and correspondent models in order to ensure greater financial inclusion and expand the reach of the banking sector. Banks now have new and varied ways to address the issue of financial inclusion thanks to provisions for this form of financial intermediation. (2006) Mahendra Dev S.

In addition to providing them with financial support options, connecting with banking services can help the poor escape the clutches of predatory lenders who frequently charge them unfair fees. To encourage financial engagement between rural people and banking institutions, developing a secure connection with the bank is a requirement. It is important to educate rural residents in general and the disadvantaged in particular about the proper issues.

To enable individuals to use contemporary technology through mobile phones, banks must reach out to the rural populace through common service centers (CSCs). The banks have the potential to act as a catalyst for empowering SHGs. The rural population can be trained and developed in modern banking techniques by banks working with NGOs (such as tele-banking). The people will gain from this, but it will also improve bank transactions, which will help the banks.

Reasons of Uneven Financial Inclusion in India

Inclusion in the financial system has a long history in India. Individual and household income levels, as well as the price of financial services, influence the alternatives for saving money. The rural populace cannot access the services if they lack the funds to pay the fee. Consumers will switch away from more expensive goods and services in favor of less expensive substitutes when prices rise. As a result, as an individual's wealth increases, so does demand, pushing the demand curve upward at all consumption rates. Consumers will switch away from less expensive, inferior goods and services in favor of more expensive alternatives as wealth increases. It is significant to remember that in India, receiving bank services frequently entails paying fees that some individuals find difficult to afford. They eventually turn to unauthorized money lenders as a result of this. The major objective should be to increase the wealth, assets, or capital of the rural masses since income generation is essential for growing demand for financial services. The availability of services, particularly credit services, to the rural populace is related to the demand for creating savings accounts. The majority of rural communities, however, do not receive credit from banks because the rural populace does not meet the requirements for requesting loans from banks. Rural women suffer the most as a result of the strict requirements to access financial services, which mostly exclude the rural masses. It is not regarded as appropriate for rural women to handle household finances. They are not allowed to pursue their own education in order to support themselves. Any bank account that they open or maintain must be managed by their husband. Most significantly, they are unable to request credit because they have little or no assets to use as collateral for the loan. Women occasionally lack the right to make decisions because the male family members make the decisions even though they have money to guarantee the loan.

 It has been discovered that women in India experience greater rejection rates for loans than men. understood to refer to establishing new bank branches in unbanked and rural areas. To provide formal financial services across the entire nation, adding bank branches in previously unbanked areas is no longer considered to be sufficient for financial inclusion. Direct transfers utilizing technology have been considered in the context of the different limitations in the delivery of subsidies. The beneficiary must maintain a minimum of one bank account. The emphasis will be on opening electronic accounts because it is logistically difficult to open that many brick and mortar physical branches. Technology adaptation would be a crucial component of this financial inclusion plan. The major goal of rural financial inclusion is to connect the rural populace with banking services for those who continue to fall outside the scope of traditional banking. It is necessary to do this by teaching the previously unconnected rural population about the many routes they might take to access the services, which call for the establishing of bank accounts with the bank. Bank-affiliated SHGs are gaining popularity as a low-cost alternative to traditional methods of providing financial services to the underprivileged. Therefore, improved SHG empowerment would mark an important turning point in the financial inclusion effort. 

Although SHGs are becoming more significant as a source of credit for the poor and marginalized, there is no proof of their efficient internal operation. Around the world, more than one billion individuals have access to mobile phones, according to an estimate. But 2.6 billion individuals worldwide lack access to banking services (Dermish et al. 2011). Banks have been permitted to use the services of NGOs, self-help groups, MFIs, and other civil society organizations as intermediaries in providing financial and banking services through the use of business facilitator and correspondent models in order to ensure greater financial inclusion and expand the reach of the banking sector. Provisions for this type of financial intermediation, according to Mahendra Dev S. (2006), have made it possible for banks to address the issue of financial inclusion in new and interesting ways (Mahendra Dev S. 2006). Connecting with banking services not only opens up financial support options for them, but it also prepares the road for the impoverished to be freed from the grips of unscrupulous money lenders. Before encouraging financial connection between rural people and banking institutions, a secure relationship with the bank is necessary. It is important to raise awareness among rural residents in general and the disadvantaged in particular. To enable individuals to use contemporary technology like mobile phones, banks need to reach out to the rural populace through common service centers (CSCs). The banks have the potential to act as a catalyst for empowering SHGs. In partnership with non-governmental organizations, banks can offer training and development programs on contemporary banking techniques to rural populations (such as tele-banking). The people will gain from this, but it will also improve bank transactions, which will benefit the banks.

Uneven Growth of India

In India, financial inclusion is more of an interconnected than an autonomous phenomenon. It is not possible to achieve rural financial inclusion solely by expanding banking services there. At the same time, the demand for banking services must rise. However, the demand for financial services as well as their availability are denied to rural India. People's demand won't rise until they have enough assets to pay for those services, according to the explanations.

In India, the GDP of agriculture has fallen while the GDP of services has steadily increased. However, the majority of people in rural India depend on agriculture for a living. Therefore, it is challenging to increase the rural population's demand for financial services in the absence of a stable source of income. According to the Socio-Economic Census of 2011, nearly three-fourths of rural households had monthly incomes of less than Rs 5000. More than half of rural households lack land and employ primarily casual labor.

One of the most valuable resources for any generation seeking a living is education. The state of rural India lags significantly behind that of urban India, where universal literacy has yet to be reached, even in metropolitan India. Male and female literacy rates in urban India are 88.76 and 79.11, respectively, compared to 77.15 and 57.93 in rural India, according to the 2011 Population Census. It demonstrates that the rural population in India has fewer opportunities to comprehend and make use of the country's financial services.

Similar disparities exist in health care between urban and rural India. The disparity in India's growth between rural and urban areas can be seen in the infant mortality rate, anemic children, women, and pregnant women, the incidence of underweight children, and awareness of various ailments. When infrastructure is considered, the disparity in development between rural and urban areas becomes more obvious. In terms of roads, electrification, drinking water, sanitation, government and non-government institutions, etc., rural India lags considerably behind urban India.

All of the aforementioned factors have a negative impact on rural residents' general standard of living, and Indians without stable incomes find it challenging to participate in the country's formal financial systems. In other words, every barrier to securing people's means of subsistence has a negative impact on the demand for financial services. In addition to the previously noted uneven development of banking services in India, in terms of income generation,

According to the Reserve Bank of India, there are only 7.8 bank branches per 100,000 people in rural and semi-urban areas, and there are 18.7 branches in urban and metropolitan areas, according to the Reserve Bank of India. In India, there are 82,794 total rural bank branches out of a total population of 1065 million, whereas there are only 43,910 urban bank branches out of a total population of 235 million. Because there are more bank branches in urban areas, it can be seen that people in India have access to more financial services.

In rural and semi-urban areas, there are 189 million savings bank accounts, compared to 139 million in urban and metropolitan areas. If we look at the overall population of rural India, we can see that there are far fewer saving bank accounts in rural and semi-urban areas than in urban and metropolitan areas. Additionally, if we look at the percentage of deposits in bank accounts, rural areas in India account for about 10% of all savings. (Indian Reserve Bank, 2015).

Concluding Remarks: 

Financial inclusion is the process of ensuring that vulnerable groups, such as weaker segments and low-income groups, have access to suitable financial support systems at an accessible price, in a fair and transparent manner by mainstream institutional players. The poor and other vulnerable groups in society, as well as rural residents in particular, suffer from a lack of access to financial institutions.

Thus, financial inclusion cannot be realized until both the demand for and the availability of cheap banking services are increased. More rural people should have access to banking services. The power of the populace should also be increased in terms of their wealth, health, and education so that they have better access to those financial services. Additionally, attention must be paid to reducing inequality between India's rural and urban areas. More than 70% of the people in India reside in rural areas. Thus, improving rural India will lead to a better India.

Reference

  1. Ahmed Dermish, Christoph Kneiding, Paul Leishman & Ignacio Mas, 2012, “Branchless and mobile banking solutions for the poor”. http://www.mitpressjournals.org/doi/pdf/10.1162/INOV_a_00103 
  2. Dasgupta, Rajaram (2009). Two Approaches to Financial Inclusion. Economic and Political Weekly. Vol. 44, No. 26/27 (Jun. 27 - Jul. 10, 2009), pp. 41-44. http://www.jstor.org/stable/40279775 
  3. Dev S. Mahendra (2006). Financial Inclusion: Issues and Challenges. Economic and Political Weekly, Vol. 41, No. 41 (Oct. 14-20, 2006), pp. 4310-4313. http://www.jstor.org/stable/4418799 
  4. Leeladhar, V (2006): "Taking Banking Services to the Common Man – Financial Inclusion", RBI Bulletin, January: 73-77. 
  5. Rajalaxmi Kamath, Arnab Mukherji and Maria Sandström A Demand Side Story for Rural India. Economic and Political Weekly. Vol. 45, No. 37 (SEPTEMBER 11-17, 2010), pp. 56-62. http://www.jstor.org/stable/25742071

Comments

Thank You